Violin plots visualizing Mehr et al.’s (2018) previous experimental results of sight vs. sound effects in judging piano performances (data were not visualized in the original publication). Panels a-c correspond to Studies 1-3 (see text for details).
Dots indicate individual participants (a: n=375 participants; b: n=300 participants; c: n=150 participants), large dots indicate means and bars indicate 95% confidence intervals. The colour legend indicates whether the 6-second excerpts participants played were audiovisual, audio-only, or visual-only. The y-axis indicates the percent of performers correctly choosing the winning performer. Dashed lines indicate chance levels (33% when choosing between 3 performers, 50% when choosing between only 2).