This article examines the practice of using the famous oboe theme Scéne, Moderato from Tchaikovsky’s Swan Lake in horror films. A long-forgotten arrangement of it, found in the New York Public Library, helps to trace the origins of this practice in silent film and to document the beginning of the association between the Swan theme and vampires, specifically. The relationship between the two has proven to be a strong one and, crossing over from silent to sound film, has continued for almost a hundred years, from the iconic Dracula (1931) to the recent Abigail (2024). Analysis of the musical features of the Moderato and the individual narrative elements of Tchaikovsky’s ballet shows that its use in horror films is not as strange as it might first seem and sound, but rather has an intrinsic rationale. If it was an accidental discovery of the filmmakers, it has nonetheless proven successful. Even though Tchaikovsky did not directly refer to the topos of horror in this movement, the generalized and indirect features appeared to be sufficient to combine it with the images of vampires on the screen to form an audiovisual metaphor of horror. For those audio-viewers who know this music first through ballet or, conversely, who have drawn their initial experiences from film, the curious fusion of the Swan theme and eerie cinematic scenes almost inevitably entails intertextual and intergenre crossovers. Ultimately, the case study of Swan Lake in horror film enriches our notions of this music as such and its expressive potential on the screen.
Swan Lake Horror
Kirill Smolkin is a doctoral candidate at Heidelberg University. In 2022 he graduated summa cum laude in Musicology at Moscow Tchaikovsky Conservatory. Alongside his studies, he also gained professional experience as an editor of the online encyclopedia on Tchaikovsky directed by State Institute for Art Studies, Moscow (SIAS). His current PhD project, funded by German Academic Exchange Service (DAAD) and supervised by Dr. Christoph Flamm, is devoted to the reception of Tchaikovsky’s work in subsequent classical music and mass culture. His other research interests include interdisciplinary music studies, film music, painting and music, and word and music studies.
This article is based in part on the presentation “Tchaikovsky in Hollywood: Reception of Peter Tchaikovsky’s Music in American Films,” delivered on 26 May 2024 in New York at the Music and the Moving Image XX Conference. Both texts, in turn, were produced in the course of my ongoing PhD project on the compositional reception of Tchaikovsky’s music, which is being carried out at the Heidelberg University, Germany under the supervision of Prof. Dr. Christoph Flamm and funded by the German Academic Exchange Service (DAAD). I thank Gillian B. Anderson, Marguerite Chabrol, Christoph Flamm, Berthold Hoeckner, Julia Khait, and Elena Rovenko for their assistance.
Kirill Smolkin; Swan Lake Horror. 19th-Century Music 1 November 2024; 48 (1-2): 66–75. doi: https://doi.org/10.1525/ncm.2024.48.1-2.66
Download citation file: