The later medieval remodeling of the stylistically related abbey churches of Tewkesbury and Pershore has presented the architectural historian with the problem of ascertaining the nature of the original Romanesque design. One school of thought favors a four-story elevation for choir and transepts which would have entailed a wood roof; the other, while not agreeing on the number of stories, suggests the reconstruction of high barrel vaults. Detailed analysis of both fabrics in the context of West Country architecture after the Conquest and select French Romanesque structures will demonstrate the original existence of a three-story scheme with barrel vaults over the main spans.

[Footnotes]

[Footnotes]
J. Philip McAleer, "The Romanesque Transept and Choir Elevations of Tewkesbury and Per- shore," appeared in The Art Bulletin, 64 (1982), 549-56310.2307/3050267
549
1
J. L. Petit, The Abbey Church of Tewkesbury, Cheltenham, 1848
Petit
The Abbey Church of Tewkesbury
1848
T. Blashill, Associated Architectural Reports and Papers, 14 (1877-1878), oz2
Blashill
oz2
14
Associated Architectural Reports and Papers
1877
A. Hartshorne, "Tewkesbury Abbey Church," Archaeological Journal, 47 (1900), 290-301
Hartshorne
290
47
Archaeological Journal
1900
J. Bony, "Tewkesbury et Pershore: Deux elevations ' quatre 6tages de la fin du XIe siecle," Bulletin Monumental, 96 (1937), 281-290, 503-504
Bony
281
96
Bulletin Monumental
1937
E. G. Benson, "What was the original apse of Tewkesbury like?" Transactions of the Bristol and Gloucestershire Archaeological Society, 67 (1946-1948), 402
Benson
402
67
Transactions of the Bristol and Gloucestershire Archaeological Society
1946
A. W. Clapham, "The Form of the Early Choir of Tewkesbury and its Significance," Archaeological Journal, 106 (Supplement) (1949), 10-15
Clapham
10
106
Archaeological Journal
1949
P. Kidson, A History of English Architecture, Harmondsworth, 1965, 54, 55-58, 62
Kidson
54
A History of English Architecture, Harmondsworth
1965
The Victoria History of the Counties of England: Gloucestershire, 8 (1968), 154-161
154
8
The Victoria History of the Counties of England: Gloucestershire
1968
M. Thurlby, "Romanesque Sculpture at Tewkesbury Abbey," Transactions of the Bristol and Gloucestershire Ar- chaeological Society, 98 (1980), 91-94
Thurlby
91
98
Transactions of the Bristol and Gloucestershire Archaeological Society
1980
A. W. Clapham in The Victoria History of the Counties of England: Worcestershire, 4 (1924), '59
Clapham
59
4
The Victoria History of the Counties of England: Worcestershire
1924
R. Stalley and M. Thurlby, "A Note on the Architecture of Pershore Abbey,"Journal of the British Archaeological Association, Ser. III, 37 (1974), 113-118
Stalley
Ser. III
113
37
Journal of the British Archaeological Association
1974
2
Blas- hill, Architectural Reports, 102
Blashill
102
Architectural Reports
R. K. Morris, "Tewkesbury Abbey: The Despenser Mausoleum," Transactions of the Bristol and Gloucestershire Ar- chaeological Society, 93 (1974), 142-155
Morris
142
93
Transactions of the Bristol and Gloucestershire Archaeological Society
1974
J. Bony, The English Decorated Style: Gothic Architecture Transformed 150-1350, Oxford, 1979, 37-38, 51-52
Bony
37
The English Decorated Style: Gothic Architecture Transformed
1979
Stalley and Thurlby, "Pershore," 113-118
Stalley
113
Pershore
3
Bony, "Deux 616vations," 281-290, 503-504.
Bony
281
Deux 616vations
R. Branner, "Gothic Architecture 1160-1180 and its Roman- esque Sources," Romanesque and Gothic Art: Studies in Western Art: Acts of the Twentieth International Congress of the History of Art, I, Princeton, x963, 65
Branner
Gothic Architecture 1160-1180 and its Romanesque Sources
65
I
Romanesque and Gothic Art: Studies in Western Art: Acts of the Twentieth International Congress of the History of Art
1963
C. Seymour, Jr., Notre Dame of Noyon in the Twelfth Century, Norton Library Edition, New York, 1968, 116
Seymour
116
Notre Dame of Noyon in the Twelfth Century, Norton Library Edition
1968
W. Stoddard, Art and Architecture in Medieval France, New York, 1972, 122
Stoddard
122
Art and Architecture in Medieval France
1972
L. Grodecki, Gothic Architecture, New York, 1977, 45
Grodecki
45
Gothic Architecture
1977
4
N. Pevsner, The Buildings of England: Worcestershire, Harmonds- worth, 1968, 14.
Pevsner
14
The Buildings of England: Worcestershire
1968
Both Petit, Tewkesbury, 22
Petit
22
Tewkesbury
Hartshorne, "Tewkes- bury," 294
Hartshorne
294
Tewkesbury
5
W. Dugdale, Monasticon Anglicanum, ii, London, 1819, 53.
Dugdale
53
ii
Monasticon Anglicanum
1819
6
Dugdale, Monasticon, In, 53.
Dugdale
53
Monasticon
7
Dugdale, Monasticon, 11, 53.
Dugdale
11
Monasticon
8
Bony, "Deux 'lvations," 285-288.
Bony
285
Deux 'lvations
9
Clapham, "Early Choir," 10-15.
Clapham
10
Early Choir
"Tewkesbury," 561-562, Fig. 23
McAleer
561
Tewkesbury
M. Thurlby, "The Elevations of the Romanesque Abbey Churches of St Mary at Tewkesbury and St Peter at Gloucester," The British Ar- chaeological Association Conference Transactions, 7, forthcoming
Thurlby
The Elevations of the Romanesque Abbey Churches of St Mary at Tewkesbury and St Peter at Gloucester
7
The British Archaeological Association Conference Transactions
10
O. Lehmann- Brockhaus, Lateinische Schriftquellen zur Kunst in England, Wales und Schottland vomJahre 900 bis zumJahre 1307, ii, Munich, 1956, 560, no. 4357
Lehmannbrockhaus
560
ii
Lateinische Schriftquellen zur Kunst in England, Wales und Schottland vomJahre 900 bis zumJahre 1307
1956
11
Bony, "Deux el'vations," 287.
Bony
287
Deux el'vations
12
Clapham, Victoria History: Gloucestershire, 158.
Clapham
158
Victoria History: Gloucestershire
D. Verey, The Buildings ofEngland: Gloucestershire: The Vale and the Forest of Dean, Harmondsworth, 1970, 361
Verey
361
The Buildings ofEngland: Gloucestershire: The Vale and the Forest of Dean
1970
15
McAleer, "Tewkesbury," Fig. 9
McAleer
Tewkesbury
16
McAleer, "Tewkesbury," Fig. 11
McAleer
Tewkesbury
17
J. Britton, Cathedral Antiquities of Great Britain, III, London, 1836, P1. xI.
Britton
III
Cathedral Antiquities of Great Britain
1836
19
Congres Archeologique, 91 (1927), 261-270
261
91
Congres Archeologique
1927
20
G. Zarnecki, Later English Romanesque Sculpture, 1140- 2rzo, London, 1953
Zarnecki
Later English Romanesque Sculpture
1953
L. Stone, Sculpture in Britain: The Middle Ages, Harmondsworth, 1955
Stone
Sculpture in Britain: The Middle Ages
1955
F. Henry and G. Zarnecki, "Romanesque Arches Decorated with Human and Animal Heads," Journal of the British Ar- chaeological Association, Ser. III, zo-zi (1957-1958), 1-34
Henry
Ser. III
1
20
Journal of the British Archaeological Association
1957
21
A. W. Clapham, English Roman- esque Architecture After the Conquest, Oxford, 1934, 52, 53
Clapham
52
English Romanesque Architecture After the Conquest
1934
22
R. Crozet. L'Art Roman en Saintonge, Paris, 1971, P1. xxvb
Crozet
L'Art Roman en Saintonge
1971
Talmont (Charente-Maritime), Congrs Archiologique, 114 (1956), 193, and 187
Talmont
193
114
Congrs Archiologique
1956
Rioux (Charente-Maritime), Congies Archiologique, 114 (1956), 129
Rioux
129
114
Congies Archiologique
1956
Retaud (Charente-Infbrieure), Congrés Archiologique, 114 (1956), 134-135
Retaud
134
114
Congrés Archiologique
1956
Saint- Maurice (Vienne), Congres Archiologique, 109 (1951), 325
Vienne
325
109
Congres Archiologique
1951
Chalivoy-Mi- lon (Cher), Congrés Archiologique, 94 (1931), pl. opp. 460
Cher
94
Congrés Archiologique
1931
Nourray (Loire- et-Cher), F. Lesueur, Les Eglises de Loire-et-Cher, Paris, 1969, 272-273, P1. xxix
Lesueur
272
Les Eglises de Loire-et-Cher
1969
Thiams (Charente-Infbrieure), F. Eygun, Saintonge Romane, La Pierre qui Vire, 1970, pls. 37, 39
Eygun
Saintonge Romane, La Pierre qui Vire
1970
23
T.S.R. Boase, English Art 1100- 1216, Oxford, 1953, pl. I
Boase
English Art 11001216
1953
Eygun, Saintonge, pl. 22
Eygun
Saintonge
24
R. Crozet, "Eglises romanes I deambulatoire entre Loire et Gi- ronde," Bulletin Monumental, 95 (1936), 61-73.
Crozet
61
95
Bulletin Monumental
1936
J. Bony, "La chapelle episcopale de Hereford et les apports lorrains en Angleterre apres la conqu^te," Actes du XIXe Congres International d'Histoire de l'Art, Paris, 1958, 42-43
Bony
La chapelle episcopale de Hereford et les apports lorrains en Angleterre apres la conqu^te
42
Actes du XIXe Congres International d'Histoire de l'Art
1958
Kidson, English Architecture, 52
Kidson
52
English Architecture
Crozet, "Eglises romanes," 65
Crozet
65
Eglises romanes
G. Webb, Architecture in Britain: The Middle Ages, Harmondsworth, 1956, 30, Fig. 17
Webb
30
Architecture in Britain: The Middle Ages
1956
25
McAleer, "Tewkes- bury," 557
McAleer
557
Tewkesbury
26
n. i
Dugdale, Monasticon, IX, 410
Dugdale
410
IX
Monasticon
27
Bony, "Deux élévations," 504
Bony
504
Deux élévations
McAleer, "Tewkesbury," Fig. 21
McAleer
Tewkesbury
28
Bony, "Deux 6lvations," 503-504.
Bony
503
Deux 6lvations
McAleer, "Tewkesbury," Fig. 22
McAleer
Tewkesbury
30
Clapham, Victoria History: Worcestershire, 160.
Clapham
160
Victoria History: Worcestershire
R. Styles, The History and Antiquities of the Abbey Church ofPershore, London, 1838, opposite p. 21
21
31
C.A.R. Radford, Ewenny Priory, London, 1976
Radford
Ewenny Priory
1976
Roger Stalley, "Three Irish Buildings with West Country Origins," Medieval Art and Architecture at Wells and Glastonbury: British Archaeological Association Conference Transactions for the year 1978, 4 (1981), 80
Stalley
Three Irish Buildings with West Country Origins
80
4
Medieval Art and Architecture at Wells and Glastonbury: British Archaeological Association Conference Transactions for the year 1978
1981
N. Pevsner, Worces- tershire, 14, 179
Pevsner
14
Worcestershire
M. Thurlby, "A Note on the former barrel vault in the choir of St John the Baptist at Halesowen and its place in English Romanesque Archi- tecture," Transactions of the Worcestershire Archaeological Society, in press
Thurlby
A Note on the former barrel vault in the choir of St John the Baptist at Halesowen and its place in English Romanesque Architecture
Transactions of the Worcestershire Archaeological Society
32
Stalley, "Irish Buildings," Pl. xva
Stalley
Irish Buildings
33
McAleer, "Tewkesbury," 555-556, Figs. 2, 13
McAleer
555
Tewkesbury
34
Stalley and Thurl- by, "Pershore," 113-118
Stalley
113
Pershore
36
S. E. Rigold, Lilleshall Abbey, London, 1969
Rigold
Lilleshall Abbey
1969
37
McAleer, "Tewkesbury," Fig. 5
McAleer
Tewkesbury
38
McAleer, "Tewkesbury," 558
McAleer
558
Tewkesbury
39
H.J.L.J. Masse, The Cathedral Church of Gloucester, London, 1898, 78
Masse
78
The Cathedral Church of Gloucester
1898
41
McAleer, "Tewkesbury," Fig. 15
McAleer
Tewkesbury
42
Boase, English Art, pl. x
Boase
English Art
44
C. Lynam, "Notes on the nave of Chepstow Parish Church," Archaeological journal, 62 (1905), 271-278.
Lynam
271
62
Archaeological journal
1905
45
Archaeological journal, 34 (1877), 323-348, pl. opp. 328..
323
34
Archaeological journal
1877
46
Clapham, English Romanesque, 55, 56, 56
Clapham
55
English Romanesque
n. 9
47
R. Branner, "Gothic 1160-1180"
Branner
Gothic 1160-1180
This content is only available via PDF.