Political Zionism is based on the fallacy that there exists a single nation encompassing all the world's Jews. How can Zionism claim that Israel is the nation-state of the Jewish people, since the only attribute shared by all Jews is Judaism, a religion and not an attribute of nationhood in any modern sense of the word? Jews can belong to various nations—a Jew may be French, American, Indian, Argentinian, and so forth—but being Jewish excludes other religious affiliations. Thus, this essay argues, the Zionist claim that all the world's Jews constitute a single distinct national entity is an ideological myth, invented as a misconceived way of dealing with the persecution and discrimination suffered by European Jews, in particular. Indeed, from its earliest iterations and up to the present day, Zionism—a colonizing project—has been fueled by an inverted form of anti-Semitism: if, as it claims, Israel acts on behalf of all Jews everywhere, then all Jews must be collectively held responsible for the actions of that state—clearly an anti-Semitic position.
An Immoral Dilemma: The Trap of Zionist Propaganda
Moshé Machover, born in Palestine in 1936, is an expatriate Israeli dissident and cofounder, in 1962, of the Socialist Organization in Israel, Matzpen. He is a mathematician, professor emeritus at King's College London, and a socialist political activist.
- Views Icon Views
- PDF LinkPDF
- Share Icon Share
- Search Site
Moshé Machover; An Immoral Dilemma: The Trap of Zionist Propaganda. Journal of Palestine Studies 1 August 2018; 47 (4): 69–78. doi: https://doi.org/10.1525/jps.2018.47.4.69
Download citation file: