Who does a personalist authoritarian ruler designate as their successor, and what makes the transition of presidency to them peaceful in the short term? This article argues that these questions can be fruitfully approached from the perspective of political legitimacy, thus contributing to the further conceptualization of legitimacy in autocracies. By analyzing the 2019 leadership succession in Kazakhstan, the article develops a model of multi-level legitimacy that differentiates between three interconnected levels of legitimacy enjoyed by political actors among the general population, the elite, and the international community. The article tracks the legitimation process and the estimated level of legitimacy of three key political actors (Nazarbaev, Tokaev, and Nazarbaeva) from the immediate pre-resignation period until the political crisis of January 2022, covering both phases of succession: Nazarbaev’s exit from and Tokaev’s entry to power. To estimate the actors’ level of legitimacy on the three analytical levels of the model, the article draws from a diverse dataset consisting of public opinion polls, expert commentary, and international actors’ statements. The article finds that in the initial transition process, the estimated level of legitimacy enjoyed by both Nazarbaev and Tokaev was relatively high in all three levels, in contrast to Nazarbaeva’s. It argues that Nazarbaev’s and Tokaev’s legitimacy contributed to the transition’s initial peaceful nature, but Nazarbaeva’s legitimacy deficit resulted in her marginalization in the succession process. The political turmoil of January 2022 demonstrates that a succession that is peaceful in the short term can paradoxically contain the seeds of a succession conflict erupting later.
Skip Nav Destination
Article navigation
December 2024
Research Article|
February 01 2024
Three Levels of Authoritarian Legitimacy: Successor Designation and Peaceful to Non-Peaceful Leadership Transition in Kazakhstan
Kristiina Silvan
Finnish Institute of International Affairs, Helsinki, Finland
email: [email protected]
Search for other works by this author on:
email: [email protected]
Communist and Post-Communist Studies (2024) 57 (4): 56–78.
Citation
Kristiina Silvan; Three Levels of Authoritarian Legitimacy: Successor Designation and Peaceful to Non-Peaceful Leadership Transition in Kazakhstan. Communist and Post-Communist Studies 1 December 2024; 57 (4): 56–78. doi: https://doi.org/10.1525/cpcs.2024.1996171
Download citation file:
Sign in
Don't already have an account? Register
Client Account
You could not be signed in. Please check your email address / username and password and try again.
Could not validate captcha. Please try again.