This essay attempts to develop some ideas about national identity as envisioned in the "Aeneid", with two foci: the lack of clarity concerning Aeneas' own nationality, and the inaccuracies in the descriptions of the foreigners portrayed on Aeneas' Vulcanian shield. I aim to undermine the notion that Vergil's own generation and Augustus' regime should be assumed to be the "climax," "culmination," or "fulfillment" of the historical process as the "Aeneid" imagines it, and to present reasons for thinking that Vergil's audience was being invited, instead, to imagine a very long-range future-to expand for themselves the scope of the poem and meet its challenge. I discuss the possibility that Vergil himself was not born either Roman or technically Italian and mention also the probable high proportion of his original audience born without the Roman franchise and admitted to it in the 80s or in 49. I argue that the extended historical range-finder through which the poem requires its readers to view themselves and their inheritors is designed to impose upon them the task of seeking a version of mos (civilized traditional customs) that can be made universal, and the task also of regarding present opponents as destined future fellow-Romans.

[Footnotes]

[Footnotes]
1
Anderson 1983
Bonjour 1975
Miles 1995.
2
Harrison 1990:1-120
Johnson 1976
3
Bonjour 1975
4
Zetzel 1989.
5
Eclogue 9.46-49.
6
Eclogue 9.47.
Scott 1941:257-72, esp. 258-59.
7
Carcopino 1930:30-37.
8
Alföldi 1930:369.
10
Chilver 1941:7-15.
Brunt 1971:168.
11
Little 1982:258
12
Brunt 1971:204-65
Badian 1968 ch. 5.
13
Gabba's summary (1976:123)
Klingner 1979:23-25
14
Brunt 1988:135-36
Gabba 1976:99
15
Brunt 1971, especially chs. 6-9.
Brunt and Moore 1967:51.
Nicolet 1980:23.
16
Whatmough 1971 passim.
17
Dyson 1992:59
Pallottino 1991:139
Klingner 1979:21.
18
Brunt 1988:117
n. 80
Gabba 1976:77 (Rhomaioi) and 101.
19
Badian 1970-1971:402
Gabba 1976:70-96.
Beard and Crawford 1985:81.
20
Syme 1939:88.
Dyson 1992:65.
21
C. Gracchus frr. 48-49 in Malcovati 1953:191-92
Aulus Gellius NA 10.3
D'Arms 1984:440-67, esp. 440-41.
22
Velleius Paterculus 2.15.
Brunt 1988:126
23
Syme 1939:286.
24
Pro L. Murena 75
Beard and Crawford 1985:79-80
25
Lowenthal 1985:213.
Lowenthal 1994:47.
Miles 1995:55.
Connor 1990
26
Syme 1939
Momigliano 1940.
Gabba 1976:96-97
27
Wilson 1966:94.
Brunt 1971:206-209
28
"A Matter of Identity," Sacks 1985:108-15.
29
Greene 1982:10.
31
Renan 1947:904.
Bhabha 1990
35
Nepotes also at 7.99
36
Bettini 1997 (this issue)
Greene 1986.
38
F. Cairns 1977.
39
Harrison 1977:130
40
Sherwin-White 1973:115-16.
Horsfall 1976:73-89, especially 82-85.
41
Toll 1991:4.
42
super et Garamantos et Indos 6.792
43
Gransden 1976:178 (in loc.)
Horace C. 1.35.32
Nisbet and Hubbard 1989:399
44
Gurval 1995:242
45
Life of Mark Antony 61
46
Gurval 1995:35
47
Gurval 1995:239-42.
48
Paduska 1970:33-34 and 46.
49
Hexter 1990:109-31.
51
Gurval 1995:240
Gurval 1995:35-36.
52
Rudd 1986:27-42
53
Fowler 1990:51.
54
Momigliano 1940:79.
56
Earl 1967, esp. pp. 21-26.
57
De Officiis 1.15
Litchfield 1914:9
charts pp. 28-35.
Lind 1979:7-58.
Inst. 12.2.30
58
Williams 1983:238.
59
O'Hara 1990:84.
Gruen 1992, esp. pp. 29-31
McKay 1970:156
Galinsky 1969
60
Harrison 1984
Feeney 1984.
62
Thompson 1984.
Halle 1972
Cuthbertson 1975
Gillis 1994
Rudy J. Koshar says succinctly, "National identity is based on the decentering and suppression of other, 'non-national' identities" (229).
63
Lind 1979:12
64
Horsfall 1976:84.

Works Cited

Works Cited
Alfoldi, A. 1930. "Der Neue Weltherrscher der Vierten Ekloge Vergils." Hermes 65:369- 84.
Anderson, Benedict. 1983. Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. London.
Badian, E. 1968. Roman Imperialism in the Late Republic. Ithaca, N.Y.
Badian, E. 1970-1971. "Roman Politics and the Italians (133-91 B.c.)" DArch 2-3:373- 421.
Beard, Mary and Michael Crawford. 1985. Rome in the Late Republic. Ithaca, N.Y.
Bettini, Maurizio. 1997. "Ghosts of Exile: Doubles and Nostalgia in Virgil's parva Troia (Aeneid 3.294ff.)." ClAnt 16.1.
Bhabha, Homi K., ed. 1990. Nation and Narration. London.
Bonjour, Madeleine. 1975. Terre Natale: Étude sur une composante affective du patri- otisme romain. Paris.
Brunt, P. A., and J. M. Moore, eds. 1967. Res Gestae Divi Augusti: The Achievements of the Divine Augustus. Oxford.
Brunt, P. A. 1971. Italian Manpower 225 B.C.-A.D. 14. Oxford.
Brunt, P. A. 1988. The Fall of the Roman Republic and Related Essays. Oxford.
Cairns, F. 1977. "Geography and Nationalism in the Aeneid." LCM 2:109-16.
Carcopino, Jérôme. 1930. Virgile et le mystère de la IVe Églogue. Paris.
Cardwell, Richard A., and Janet Hamilton, eds. 1986. Virgil in a Cultural Tradition: Essays to Celebrate the Bimillenium. Nottingham.
Chilver, G. E. F. 1941. Cisalpine Gaul: Social and Economic History from 49 B.C. to the Death of Trajan. Oxford.
Connor, W.R. 1990. Pritchett lecture, 5 Nov. Berkeley.
Cuthbertson, Gilbert Morris. 1975. Political Myth and Epic. East Lansing, Mich.
D'Arms, John H. 1984. "Upper Class Attitudes toward Viri Municipales and their Towns in the Early Roman Empire." Athenaeum n.s. 62:440-67.
Deroux, Carl, ed. 1979. Studies in Latin Literature and Roman History I. Brussels.
Dyson, Stephen L. 1992. Community and Society in Roman Italy Baltimore.
Earl, Donald. 1967. The Moral and Political Tradition of Rome. Ithaca, N.Y.
Feeney, D. C. 1984. "The Reconciliations of Juno." CQ 34:179-94.
S. J. Harrison, ed. 1990. Oxford Readings in Vergil's Aeneid, 339-62. Oxford.
Fowler, Don. 1990. "Deviant Focalization in Virgil's Aeneid." PCPS 216 (n.s. 36):42-63.
Gabba, E. 1976. Republican Rome, the Army and the Allies. P. J. Cuff trans. Oxford.
Galinsky, G. Karl. 1969. Aeneas, Sicily, and Rome. Princeton.
Gillis, John R., ed. 1994. Commemorations: The Politics of National Identity. Princeton.
Gransden, K. W., ed. 1976. Virgil Aeneid Book VIII. Cambridge.
Greene, Thomas M. 1982. The Light in Troy: Imitation and Discovery in Renaissance Poetry. New Haven and London.
-. 1986. "History and Anachronism." In Gary Saul Morson, ed., Literature and History: Theoretical Problems and Russian Case Studies, 205-20. Stanford.
Gruen, Erich S. 1992. Culture and National Identity in Republican Rome. Ithaca, N.Y.
Gurval, Robert. 1995. Actium and Augustus: The Politics and Emotions of Civil War. Ann Arbor.
Halle, Louis J. 1972. The Ideological Imagination. Chicago.
Harrison, E. L. 1977. "Structure and Meaning in Vergil's Aeneid." LCM 2:101-12.
. 1984. "The Aeneid and Carthage." In T. Woodman and D. West, Poetry and Politics in the Age of Augustus, 95-115. Cambridge.
Harrison, S. J., ed. 1990. Oxford Readings in Vergil's Aeneid. Oxford and New York.
Harrison, S. J. 1990. "Some Views of the Aeneid in the Twentieth Century." In S. J. Harrison, ed., Oxford Readings in Vergil's Aeneid, 1-20. Oxford and New York.
Hexter, Ralph. 1990. "What Was the Trojan Horse Made Of?: Interpreting Virgil's Aeneid." Yale Journal of Criticism 3.2:109-31.
Horsfall, Nicholas. 1976. "Virgil, History, and the Roman Tradition." Prudentia 8:73-89.
Johnson, W. R. 1976. Darkness Visible. Berkeley.
Klingner, Friedrich. 1979. Römische Geisteswelt: Essays zur lateinischen Literatur. Stuttgart.
Koshar, Rudy J. 1994. "Building Pasts: Historic Preservation and Identity in Twentieth- Century Germany." In John R. Gillis, ed., Commemorations: The Politics of National Identity, 215-38. Princeton.
Lind, L. R. 1979. "The Tradition of Roman Moral Conservatism." In Carl Deroux, ed., Studies in Latin Literature and Roman History 1, 7-58. Brussels.
Litchfield, H. W. 1914. "National exempla virtutis in Roman Literature." HSCPh 25:1-71.
Little, Douglas. 1982. "Politics in Augustan Poetry." ANRW 11.30.1:254-370.
Lowenthal, David. 1985. The Past is a Foreign Country. Cambridge.
. 1994. "Identity, Heritage, and History." In John R. Gillis, ed., Commemorations: The Politics of National Identity, 41-57. Princeton.
Malcovati, Henrica. 1953. Oratorum Romanorum Fragmenta. 3rd ed. Torino.
McKay, Alexander G. 1970. Vergil's Italy. Greenwich, Ct.
Miles, Gary B. 1995. Livy: Reconstructing Early Rome. Ithaca, N.Y.
Momigliano, Amaldo. 1940. "Review and Discussion of Ronald Syme, The Roman Revolution." JRS 30:75-80.
Morson, Gary Saul, ed. 1986. Literature and History: Theoretical Problems and Russian Case Studies. Stanford, CA.
Nicolet, Claude. 1980. The World of the Citizen in Republican Rome. P. S. Falla trans. Berkeley. (French edition Paris, 1976.)
O'Hara, James J. 1990. Death and the Optimistic Prophecy in Vergil's Aeneid. Princeton.
Pallottino, Massimo. 1991. A History of Earliest Italy. Martin Ryle and Kate Soper trans. Ann Arbor. (Italian edition Milan, 1993.)
Poduska, Donald M. 1970. "Ope Barbarica or Bellum Civile?" CB 46:33-34 and 46.
Psichari, Henriette, ed. 1947. (Euvres complètes de Ernest Renan. Vol. 1. Paris.
Renan, Ernest. 1947. "Qu'est-ce qu'une nation?" In Henriette Psichari, ed., OEuvres complètes de Ernest Renan, vol. 1, 889-906. Paris (originally published 1882).
Rudd, Niall. 1986. "The Idea of Empire in the Aeneid." In Richard A. Cardwell and Janet Hamilton, eds., Virgil in a Cultural Tradition: Essays to Celebrate the Bimillenium, 25-42. Nottingham.
Sacks, Oliver. 1985. The Man Who Mistook his Wife for a Hat. London.
Scott, Kenneth. 1941. "The Sidus Iulium and the Apotheosis of Caesar." CP 36:257-72.
Sherwin-White, A. N. 1973. The Roman Citizenship. 2nd ed. Oxford.
Syme, Ronald. 1939. The Roman Revolution. Oxford.
Thom, Martin. 1990. "What is a Nation?" English trans. of Renan 1947. In Homi K. Bhabha, ed., Nation and Narration. London.
Thompson, John B. 1984. Studies in the Theory of Ideology. Oxford.
Toll, Katharine. 1991. "The Aeneid as an Epic of National Identity: Italiam Laeto Socii Clamore Salutant." Helios 18.1:3-14.
Whatmough, Joshua. 1971. The Foundations of Roman Italy. New York (first published London, 1937).
Williams, Gordon. 1983. Technique and Ideas in the Aeneid. New Haven.
Wilson, A. J. N. 1966. Emigration from Italy in the Republican Age of Rome. Manchester.
Woodman, T., and D. West, eds. 1984. Poetry and Politics in the Age of Augustus. Cambridge.
Zetzel, James E. G. 1989. "ROMANE, MEMENTO: Justice and Judgment in Aeneid 6." TAPA 119:276-82.
This content is only available via PDF.